Some physicians and scientists suggest that administering chemotherapy, immunotherapy, or radiotherapy at a specific time of day can improve response to treatment.
Safety and precautions
While chronomodulated itself does not appear to have specific safety risks, patients in one study of a chronomodulated chemotherapy schedule showed a sex difference in survival, which may reflect underlying differences in circadian rhythms. Another study found that neutropenia on chronomodulated FOLFOX chemotherapy predicted worse outcomes, though chronomodulation itself did not appear to have an effect.
Lower survival among female patients receiving chronomodulated colorectal cancer chemotherapy
Female patients with colorectal cancer showed shorter overall survival time on a chronomodulated chemotherapy schedule that increased survival among male patients compared to non-time-specified infusions.1Giacchetti S, Dugué PA et al. Sex moderates circadian chemotherapy effects on survival of patients with metastatic colorectal cancer: a meta-analysis. Annals of Oncology. 2012 Dec;23(12):3110-3116.
Shorter progression-free survival among people with stage 2b-3 prostate cancer receiving high-dose radiotherapy in the evening compared to the daytime in one observational study.2Hsu FM, Hou WH et al. Differences in toxicity and outcome associated with circadian variations between patients undergoing daytime and evening radiotherapy for prostate adenocarcinoma. Chronobiology International. 2016;33(2):210-9.
Lower survival among those with worse neutropenia during chronomodulated FOLFOX chemotherapy
Shorter survival among people with metastatic colorectal cancer with less neutropenia from circadian-aligned FOLFOX chemotherapy, compared to longer survival among those with worse neutropenia from non-time-specified FOLFOX chemotherapy in a mid-sized RCT.3Innominato PF, Giacchetti S et al. Prediction of survival by neutropenia according to delivery schedule of oxaliplatin-5-Fluorouracil-leucovorin for metastatic colorectal cancer in a randomized international trial (EORTC 05963). Chronobiology International. 2011 Aug;28(7):586-600. Note: according to the authors, this result indicates that in chronotherapy, oncologists should not always choose the highest tolerated dose as indicated by neutropenia.
In the same study, people with metastatic colorectal cancer who had worse neutropenia from FOLFOX chronotherapy (5-fluorouracil in the morning and oxaliplatin in the evening) showed worse survival, but those with less neutropenia showed better survival.
Side effects or adverse events
People with colorectal cancer experienced more skin-related side effects in two studies investigating different chronomodulated chemotherapy regimens.4Focan C, Bury J et al. Chimiothérapie adjuvante pour le cancer du colon de stades Dukes B2 et C comportant du 5-fluorouracile et de l’acide folinique, avec ou sans carboplatine. Faisabilité et comparaison d’une administration standard à une administration chronomodulée [Adjuvant chemotherapy for Dukes B2 and C colon cancer combining 5-fluorouracil and folinic acid with or without carboplatin. Feasibility and comparison between standard and chronomodulated deliveries]. Pathologie-Biologie (Paris). 2005 Jun;53(5):281-4. French; Akgun Z, Saglam S et al. Neoadjuvant chronomodulated capecitabine with radiotherapy in rectal cancer: a phase II brunch regimen study. Cancer Chemotherapy and Pharmacology. 2014 Oct;74(4):751-6.
People with metastatic breast cancer treated with chronomodulated 5-fluorouracil chemotherapy at 5 p.m. compared to other times of day experienced less leukopenia but worse gastrointestinal side effects (nausea, diarrhea, and stomach pain) compared to other times of day.5Coudert B, Focan C et al. A randomized multicenter study of optimal circadian time of vinorelbine combined with chronomodulated 5-fluorouracil in pretreated metastatic breast cancer patients: EORTC trial 05971. Chronobiology International. 2008 Sep;25(5):680-96.
Keep reading about timing of therapy
Learn more
References